Photo credit: Mike Marsland
Starlight Express ran at London’s Apollo Victoria Theatre from 1984-2002 and was recently revived at the Troubadour Theatre in Wembley, where it played from June 2024 - May 2026, directed by Luke Sheppard, designed by Tim Hatley, and choreographed by Ashley Nottingham. As the original choreographer, Dame Arlene Phillips explained to us at the gorgeous Electric Cinema in Portobello Road where we were given a sneak preview of the capture of the Wembley show last night, that the original idea to do some dance on roller skates was hers. She is credited as Creative Dramaturg on the film. Before the film was shown, we were treated to a rendition of ‘Make Up My Heart’ by Sophie Naglik, who plays Pearl in the film capture (a 1992 addition to the score) and a brief Q&A where Jeevan Braich, who plays Rusty, explained that he felt like Bambi on skates when he first went to skate school, and recalled an eight-person crash which left two cast members going to hospital!
It is a simple story, updated with Control now played by a child (the charming George Jones in the film) who is on stage throughout, creating a sense of a dreamlike imagination of a sleeping child, but there is little depth to the narrative. Rusty is a steam engine who wants to prove himself in the Championship against his main rivals: the reigning champion Greaseball (Olivia Ringrose) and the new kid on the rails Electra (Asher Forth), plus a host of other engines. Each must team up with a carriage for the race, and for some unfathomable reason, Pearl chooses other racers when we all know she should choose Rusty. Of course, he wins eventually and they are united in victory. We can see it is a story about the underdog, reaching your goals, believing in yourself and love conquering all, and those are useful messages for a young audience. But does it work as a cinema experience? What does it take to present a good capture of a stage show?
To start with, it needs an engaging piece of theatre with a unique hook to sell into cinema audiences looking through theatrical listings. There is no doubt that Andrew Lloyd Webber’s name and a forty-year global track record of success is a substantial hook, and for the legions of fans it is enough for them to book to relive their memories of the show or see how the show has evolved over the years.
It, of course, needs a clever edit of footage captured by multiple cameras over several performances to ensure they have the best shot they need to fulfil the storyboard they are aiming for. However, that means that the audience’s eye is focused to where the director has chosen, whereas in the live experience, you are free to take in the whole picture and choose your own focus. It does have some lovely close ups of the impressive costumes by Gabriella Slade that define the characters on skates. We were told that some were quite heavy and took getting used to, but they look great.
The pre-show film shows the work that had gone into the capture but in some ways, it spoils the illusion. Just like David Attenborough documentaries, you want the “making” reveal after you have been impressed by the finished product, not before you have seen the show. They do add in some bodycam footage of the three “races” in the show and overlay graphics of the running order but without that, you would have no idea what was going on. You lose the sense of danger and speed felt when they are skating around you in the auditorium and the crashes look artificial. We know it is recorded and nothing will be shown going wrong.
It is a musical so you want to hear great voices singing memorable tunes. Fans will love hearing the latest version of the libretto again but apart from the title song, which is an ear worm of a tune, the rest are a mishmash of parodies of other musical genres. We have 80’s electronic/synth, 70’s glam rock, 60’s soul and blues , 50’s rock ‘n’ roll, and even a send up of Dolly Parton’s ‘D-I-V-O-R-C-E’ with ‘U-N-C-O-U-P-L-E-D’. Only the gospel number, “Light at the End of the Tunnel’, sung by Jade Marvin as Momma, has the power to emotionally move us and together with ‘Starlight Express’ lifts our spirits.
We can admire the skating techniques, especially after the “blood sweat and tears” of ten weeks of ten-hour days in skate school. But the real excitement of that does not translate to film as it would if you experienced it all round your seat. There is no doubt this was a highly creative and original show, and remains a fun immersive experience as a live show. But on film, it is like watching a party that you were not invited to and imagining how much more fun it would have been to be in the room.
Starlight Express has many fans around the world who will enjoy this film as a celebration of a unique show, and many grandparents and parents will take their children to see it for the first time. The kids will adore it as a cross between Thomas the Tank Engine and watching computer game action on the big screen but for this reviewer, the film fails to engender the same feeling as being in the room as they swirl around you at speed and a sense that anything could happen - only live theatre can deliver that.
*** Three stars
Reviewed by: Nick Wayne