Review: DESIRE UNDER THE ELMS, Almeida Theatre

Photo credit: Marc Brenner

“I will finish what I started”, cried by the patriarch, is a pretty good summary of Eugene O’Neill’s Desire Under The Elms, and potentially a better advert for its content than the title is. Ebenezer Bamgboye’s version strips back the setting and forefront’s the emotion, in a production that tries out new ideas with the century-old source material.

Immediately apparent in this play is the importance of music. Abruptly underlining dialogue in the first half and then low-level omnipresent in the second half, George Dennis and XANA’s sound design and composition shines as it insinuates itself into the audience and bolsters the dark tone Bamgboye sets. Despite some jarringly abrupt trumpet riffs, generally the live music lifts the production and puts a personal stamp on preceding. Similarly, Jack Knowles’s lighting refuses to be ignored. From sickly greens of a family home turned rotten to a cold, tomb-like wash when the characters’ fate is sealed, the audience is kept constantly present by the precise and revelatory colours and intensities. 

Zackary Momoh is a standout. His portrayal of Eben, the overworked and overlooked heir to the farm, builds in confidence and then shatters under the pressure, with convincing echoes of the father figure he shuns woven into the performance, and a natural charisma that draws the eye. Eben’s new stepmother (and foil), Kelly Gough’s Abigail, is another strong performance, despite disorientating choices made for the character. So overtly opportunistic and insincere from the off, watching her warm into authenticity isn’t always convincing, even with Gough’s complete commitment. Antony Byrne’s patriarch Ephraim is the most complex character, given layers upon layers in his monologues, although his violent outbursts are indicated usually by a rise in volume rather than anything more insidious, which becomes repetitive and hurts Byrne’s otherwise engaging performance.

The interludes of physical theatre, directed by Rose Tyan, illustrate the trajectory of Eben and Abigail’s relationship in a way that is both violent and sensual, often at the same time, filling in the gaps left by the script. Despite the side seating being integrated into the stage, the action still feels very far removed; more like standing silently in someone’s family home while they argue than feeling like a part of the world O’Neill is conjuring.

Overall, the production is entertaining and slick, although it often feels like the source material is slightly at war with this new vision, as its stripped-back, sinister setting is betrayed in the final act by its melodrama. Bamgboye’s production strives for new meaning and sometimes succeeds, but often his modern staging and naturalist characters feel at odds with O’Neill’s archaic dialogue and domestic drama. Though the production is pacy and well-performed with some amazing sound and lighting work, it’s difficult to say what an audience might take away from it. 

Committed performances and pacy plotting.

*** Three stars

Reviewed by: Oli Burgin

Desire Under The Elms plays at London’s Almeida Theatre until 23 Dec, with further info here.

Previous
Previous

Review: SOPHIE’S SURPRISE CHRISTMAS PARTY, Underbelly Boulevard

Next
Next

Conductor Dalia Stasevska makes Royal Opera debut with Christmas favourite THE MAGIC FLUTE